Forum
Logo
banner

Login to Rethos
Email:
Password:

Not a Rethos citizen?
Not a member? sign up now
11:21 AM, APRIL 08, 2008
Dscn1911_thumb
More At Stake than the Gold
Issues: 
280 views | 5 comments
Blog Blog 
Myanmar_-_boicottaggio_inline

More At Stake Than The Gold

There are two words we have all heard a lot of over the past few days: Olympics and Protestors. Whether your co-workers are discussing it at the water cooler, or it’s the first thing you hear on the news in the morning or it’s the last thing you see on TV before you tuck yourself into bed, the topic of the 2008 Beijing Olympics torch run is as hot as the flame it holds.

So, what’s all the hype around this particular summer Olympic games? I’m almost certain most people already know the answer to that. However, in case I’m mistaken – the brief synopsis is this:

China occupied Tibet over fifty years ago and Tibet has been trying to break free ever since. Over the years, major human rights issues amongst the Tibetans have surfaced – ranging from slave labor to killing frenzies by the Chinese.

From what I can tell, the people of Tibet are not against the Olympic Games per se, rather, they are against the country holding the Olympics and their long-lasting, unaddressed human rights issues. What do we expect of these people who have been trying to get their voice heard for half a century? Tibet finally has the stage and the world is their audience.

Back to the whole torch run aspect of the pre-Olympic fever. Traditionally, the torch run is a celebratory show that sets the stage for the Olympics, however, this year it has turned into a growing confrontation over the Chinese government's religious and political persecution.

I live and work in the middle of what is likely going to be pure chaos. My office is practically in the war zone of what I can only imagine is going to be an intense, loud and highly political protest. I find it interesting that Olympic Game protests are nothing new and have been around for years.

It goes back to 1908, when Irish athletes, angered at the refusal of Britain to give Ireland its independence, boycotted the Games in London. It continued in 1936 in Berlin after Hitler took power and the Nazis drenched the games in propaganda. We’re all familiar with the tragedy that struck the Munich Olympics in 1972, or the 1980 Games in Moscow where 62 countries boycotted the event, and of course, the bomb in Atlanta in 1996.

I conclude here with my own questions and thoughts on this issue, but I really want to hear from you.

Why do you think there is this history of violence, protests and boycotting in the midst of an event that is ironically about peace, harmony and bringing the people of the world together?

Does the issue itself begin with the idea of the Olympics?

If these “games” are really about uniting the world as one, why has there always been a divide?

And, finally, can the world ever truly be united, or are we just fueling the flame by encouraging the Olympic competition amongst ourselves?

The Olympic creed is simply this, "The most important thing in the Olympic Games is not to win but to take part, just as the most important thing in life is not the triumph but the struggle. The essential thing is not to have conquered but to have fought well."

http://www.nytimes.com/2008/04/09/world/09torch.html?hp

http://afp.google.com/article/ALeqM5jj6kvYFf0F8bLOXmy2cSZp5lQrCg

http://www.mercurynews.com/othersports/ci_8848646

Rating:
mostly loved
(by 3 users)  

5 PREVIOUS COMMENTS

Bio_pic_small_thumb APR 13, 2008
Elias Feghali
Denise,

Good questions and a great prompt for discussion. My thoughts on world unity are nuanced. I believe that humans have the potential to achieve world peace - but then again, potential is only so good as it is capitalized on, and whether there is a realistic possibility for world peace is another question all together. However, we must strive so long as there is any hope at all, as daunting as the task may seem.

Thanks again for the piece. What do other people think about world unity and the Olympic boycott more specifically?

Eli
From_the_heart_of_the_world_thumb APR 14, 2008
Li Li Parsons
The "boycott" was created as an active protest against immoral practices, usually corporate, but not exclusively. In this light, protesting China's role as host of the Olympics definitely qualifies as a bonafide boycott fueled by rational considerations... If this were not the Olympic year, the ceremonies and competitions could have conceivably taken place in another country... Now that the time is here, it's impossible to change the venue, unfotunately for the athletes who are competing in the most important games of their lives!
In principle I agree with the mood to boycott China for its human rights violations, but then, I would also agree with other countries if they chose to boycott the US for the same reason, next time it''s our turn to host the Olympic games. In practice, I believe the Olympic games could be a pathway for humanity to transcend the merely political... which is why they were resurrected in the modern era to begin with.
Img_2682_thumb APR 16, 2008
Anna Miller
At the heart of any of the Olympic protests, I believe, is the contrast between the feelings of unity and harmony that the games are supposed to promote, and the cold hard truth about the way many people and countries operate. Having a country like China host these "world games" is an oxymoron, because their government does not practice unity, or acceptance.

It seems there will always be this divide, at least as long as the world continues to operate as it does. Where can the line be drawn?? It is up for us as world citizens to decide... and to speak out when we see injustice. We are truly the only people who can change things.
Rethosdefaultavatar_small APR 24, 2008
Linda
"China occupied Tibet over fifty years ago and Tibet has been trying to break free ever since. Over the years, major human rights issues amongst the Tibetans have surfaced – ranging from slave labor to killing frenzies by the Chinese."

It's true that the Tibet protestors have taken the advantage of this world event to speak for themselves, but many facts that they present to the west are wrong.
1. Dalai Lama had a slavery/feudal regime before he escaped to India. He and the monks held the most power while 95% of Tibetans were slaves without education and any rights, not to speak of the tortures done on them.
2. Tibet had always been part of China since ancient history. During the 1940s, because of China's weak status, many western countries(UK) tried to take over Tibet, and Dalai established a so called government.
3. It was a fact that troops were sent to Tibet from Chinese government right after. To those slavemasters and monks, it was invasion and a violent act to take over their country. But to the majority of slaves, it was a liberation act to free the slaves.
4. Most of the Tibetan protestors are descents of the Tibet exile government.
5. Tibet is still poor and undeveloped in comparison with many other places in China. This is why many Tibetans feel inferior and have problems with( Just like African Americans in America). If China has done anything wrong, it is by allowing the skilled workers and businessmen from other parts of China to come in. Their intention was to bring outside help to improve the local economy because the Tibetans are unskilled. However, to many Tibetans, this was taken as taking over their jobs.
5.But compared with 50 years ago, Chinese have done great development in Tibet. For example, the life expectancy has doubled, the living conditions are greatly improved, the newly built railroads enabled the opening of reclusive Tibet to the world. The government has many policies favoring Tibetans to promote better education and economy. Tibetans pay no tax, can get into good schools with lower grades than other Chinese, can have more than one child, etc.
6. Tibetans are known to be greatly religious, but most Chinese are not. The government overlooks this important point and concentrates on improving education and economy instead. The government may not have done much to improve Tibetan's spritual request, which is the area I think the government needs to improve on. However, religious practice is no means oppressed.
7. It's true that China may have as much as freedom as these democratic nations, and needs to work on them. This is an issue happening to all the people in China, not just to minorities. But to feed 1/5 of world's population, gauranteed with basic living conditions is what most Chinese are concerned instead of having anything to do with politics.
Rethosdefaultavatar_small APR 24, 2008
Linda
I'd really appreciate if you could spend some time reading the post above. I am a Chinese Canadian who was born in China and immigrated to Canada at 10. I have witnessed the drastic changes and development in China over the last decade.
I have access to both sides of the media and seen much more coverage on the Tibet protest by the western media, but not so much on the pro-China side, if any, it's always followed by satiric tones. I don't want to discuss if it's deliberate conspiracy, I am speaking out to urge the westerners see both sides of the story of this issue instead of believing what they see in media.
To speak of whether China deserves Olympics, some other issues are actually worth discussing instead of Tibet. For example, the rural poverty, pollution, etc. I admit China is not perfect, since no country is perfect, but most Chinese are very excited about the Olympics and feel proud about hosting the event.
I found that BBC has a recent series of reports on modern China worth looking at. Also, I suggest you visit China when you have a chance and see for your eyes if Chinese are living happily or being oppressed by the government. You will most certainly welcomed by Chinese

FEATURED NEWS
Where does your candidate stand on predatory lending?
Posted By: Americans for Fairness in Lending   Jul 02, 2008
Blog
...
INDIA - Hyderabad newspaper editor arrested in caste-related dispute
Posted By: Reporters sans frontières Canada   Jun 27, 2008
Article
<span...
Common Good Banks
Posted By: Common Good Finance   Jun 19, 2008
Audio_video
Sign up to help make this a reality!

MOST VIEWED
Abuse Your Friend's Toilets
Posted By: Christopher   Sep 02, 2007
Blog
Abue Your Friend's Toilets<...
Don't drink the water!
Posted By: Will   Sep 07, 2007
Article
Bottled water is healthy water – right?</p...
The Meat Industry and the Environment
Posted By: Christopher   Sep 02, 2007
Blog
Here are only a few facts from the November ...
Digging deep for capitalism
Posted By: Patrick Scott   Nov 08, 2007
Blog
Mining and particularly the mining of precio...
'Critical Mass' Acts to Promote Urban Bicycle Transporation
Posted By: Alec Henderson   Nov 09, 2007
Blog
It’s almost seven p.m. Friday night. It i...

HIGHEST RATED
Cause of Severe Hunger
Posted By: Amy's Hunger Awareness   Aug 29, 2007
Article
The cause of most hunger stems from some dis...
Race and Urban Poverty
Posted By: Ending Urban Poverty   Aug 29, 2007
Blog
Poverty twice as likely for minority ethnic ...
Homelessness
Posted By: Ending Urban Poverty   Aug 29, 2007
Blog
Homelessness is the condition and societal c...
How weird
Posted By: Jason Boyer   Aug 29, 2007
Blog
So, the world goes viral and a huge amount o...
Biodiversity Hotspots
Posted By: Evan   Aug 30, 2007
Blog
Some parts of the world with so much flora a...